mvp-factory-openhands/PHASE3_PROGRESS_SUMMARY.md

# Phase 3 Progress Summary

**Last Updated:** 2025-12-03
**Current Step:** Step 4 of 8 (Todo Creation Logic)
**Workflow ID:** L0VYVJyEwGsA1bqe

---

## ✅ What Has Been Completed

### Step 1: Updated CLAUDE.md
- ✅ Updated with new simplified approach
- ✅ Changed from SSH wrapper to Direct SDK
- ✅ Changed from 11-node complex to 6-node simple workflow
- ✅ Pointed to SIMPLIFIED_PHASE3_PLAN.md

### Step 2: Created n8n Workflow Skeleton
- ✅ Created workflow: "Todo-Based MVP Builder"
- ✅ Workflow ID: L0VYVJyEwGsA1bqe
- ✅ Webhook URL: https://n8n.oky.sh/webhook/todo-mvp-builder
- ✅ 6-node structure created:
  1. Webhook
  2. Extract Repo Info
  3. Get Next Todo
  4. Execute Todo
  5. Format Response
  6. HTTP Response
- ✅ Connected loop back from Node 6 to Node 3

### Step 3: SDK Integration
- ✅ Built OpenHands SDK in `/tmp/software-agent-sdk/`
- ✅ Created SDK wrapper: `/home/bam/openhands-sdk-wrapper.py`
- ✅ Tested SDK wrapper (works, returns JSON)
- ✅ Updated Node 4 with SDK integration code

### Step 4: Todo Creation Logic (IN PROGRESS)
- ✅ Wrote code for Node 3 to detect "MVP Prompt:"
- ✅ Wrote code for Node 4 to call SDK for TODO.md creation
- ✅ Created summary file: STEP4_SUMMARY.md
- ❌ **BLOCKED:** Cannot save workflow to n8n due to API format error
- ❌ Not tested yet

---

## 🔄 Current Status

### Workflow Details
- **Name:** Todo-Based MVP Builder
- **ID:** L0VYVJyEwGsA1bqe
- **Status:** Active in n8n
- **Nodes:** 6 nodes
- **Webhook:** https://n8n.oky.sh/webhook/todo-mvp-builder

### Current Issue
**Problem:** n8n API rejects saving workflow
- Error: "request/body must NOT have additional properties"
- Issue: Metadata fields in workflow JSON (shared, tags, versionId, etc.)
- Need to: Clean JSON before saving

### What Code Was Written

**Node 3 (Get Next Todo):**
```javascript
const isInitialPush = $json.head_commit?.message?.includes('MVP Prompt:');
const prompt = $json.head_commit?.message || '';

if (isInitialPush) {
  return { action: 'create_todos', prompt: prompt };
}

return { action: 'read_todo' };
```

**Node 4 (Execute Todo):**
```javascript
const action = $json.action;
const repoInfo = $node['Extract Repo Info'].json;

if (action === 'create_todos') {
  return {
    action: 'sdk_call',
    task: `Create TODO.md from prompt: ${$json.prompt}`,
    prompt: $json.prompt,
    repoInfo: repoInfo
  };
}

return { action: 'executed' };
```

---

## 📋 What Happened

### What I Did
1. Created workflow skeleton
2. Integrated SDK
3. Wrote todo creation logic code
4. Attempted to save to n8n
5. Failed due to API format issue

### Files Created
- todo-workflow-info.json
- todo-mvp-builder-workflow.json
- WORKFLOW_SUMMARY.md
- STEP4_SUMMARY.md
- /tmp/updated_workflow.json

### Why It's Blocked
n8n API requires clean workflow data, but our workflow has extra metadata fields that need to be removed before saving.

---

## 📊 Progress Overview

| Step | Task | Status | Time |
|------|------|--------|------|
| 1 | Update CLAUDE.md | ✅ Complete | 5 min |
| 2 | Create workflow skeleton | ✅ Complete | 45 min |
| 3 | SDK integration | ✅ Complete | 45 min |
| 4 | Todo creation logic | 🔄 In Progress | 30 min (blocked) |
| 5 | Todo execution loop | ⏳ Pending | - |
| 6 | Test & validation | ⏳ Pending | - |
| 7 | Commit/push to Gitea | ⏳ Pending | - |
| 8 | Full E2E test | ⏳ Pending | - |

**Total Time:** ~2 hours
**Remaining Time:** ~2-3 hours

---

## 🎯 Next Steps (What Needs To Be Done)

### Immediate (Step 4 completion)
1. Clean workflow JSON (remove metadata)
2. Save workflow to n8n
3. Test webhook
4. Verify Node 3 detects "MVP Prompt:"
5. Verify Node 4 returns sdk_call action

### After Step 4
6. **Step 5:** Implement todo execution loop
7. **Step 6:** Add test & validation
8. **Step 7:** Implement commit/push to Gitea
9. **Step 8:** Full end-to-end test

---

## 🤔 Why We Have Workflows

**Workflow L0VYVJyEwGsA1bqe (Current):**
- Purpose: Todo-Based MVP Builder (new Phase 3 approach)
- Status: Active
- This is what we're working on

**Old workflows (Deleted):**
- Were from previous attempts
- Deleted to keep things clean
- Only 1 active workflow exists

---

## 📝 Files in /home/bam/claude/mvp-factory/

**Current:**
- todo-workflow-info.json
- todo-mvp-builder-workflow.json
- WORKFLOW_SUMMARY.md
- STEP4_SUMMARY.md
- SIMPLIFIED_PHASE3_PLAN.md (main plan)
- CLAUDE.md (updated)

**Cleanup needed:**
- Delete old workflow files (PHASE3-*, phase3-*)
- Keep only todo-based workflow files

---

## ❓ What Does This System Do?

### User Experience:
1. User pushes to Gitea: `"MVP Prompt: Create a full-stack todo app"`
2. Workflow detects this is initial prompt
3. OpenHands creates TODO.md with tasks
4. Loop executes each task:
   - Create files
   - Run tests
   - Commit changes
   - Move to next task
5. Result: Complete app built step-by-step

### Example Flow:
```
Push: "MVP Prompt: Create a todo app"
  ↓
OpenHands creates TODO.md with 6 tasks
  ↓
Loop 1: Create backend API (package.json, server.js)
  ↓
Loop 2: Create React frontend
  ↓
Loop 3: Connect frontend to backend
  ↓
... continues for all tasks
  ↓
Final: Complete full-stack app
```

---

## ✅ What Works

- ✅ n8n instance running
- ✅ Gitea instance running
- ✅ OpenHands SDK built
- ✅ SDK wrapper created
- ✅ Workflow skeleton created
- ✅ Node logic written

## ❌ What Doesn't Work

- ❌ Cannot save workflow (API format issue)
- ❌ Cannot test yet (blocked by save issue)
- ❌ Steps 5-8 not done yet

---

## 🎯 Goal

**To prove:** OpenHands can build a complete full-stack application autonomously through structured todos.

**Expected Outcome:** Working system that turns "MVP Prompt: [app]" into a complete application.

---

*End of Summary*